Criminal defense software: what case management must handle
Court dates, discovery, privilege, co-defendant conflicts, flat-fee agreements and jail visit logs: a buyer’s guide for criminal defense firms.
Last updated October 22, 2026
What should criminal defense case management software do?
Criminal defense case management software should calendar every court date, organize discovery as it arrives, protect privileged material, run conflict checks against co-defendants, witnesses and alleged victims, and log jail calls and visits. Billing should support flat fees and written fee agreements, since contingent fees are not allowed for criminal defendants.
Get started with Legal Practice Management
Sign up and our team will walk you through Perimattic Legal Practice Management for your firm’s intake, billing and trust accounting.
Sign upWhat does a criminal defense matter need from software at each stage?
Criminal matters move on the court’s schedule, not the firm’s, and the first call often comes from a family member after an arrest. Each stage asks something different of your software:
| Stage | What happens | What the software must do |
|---|---|---|
| First contact | A family member or the accused calls after an arrest or a summons | Capture the caller, the accused, the charge, the court and the next date; collect co-defendant and alleged victim names |
| Conflict check | The firm checks it can take the case | Search co-defendants, witnesses and alleged victims against all current, former and prospective clients |
| Engagement | Fee agreement signed, usually a flat fee | Record the scope, fee and any stage-based terms; deposit advance fees as your state requires |
| Arraignment and hearings | Court dates set and frequently reset | Calendar each date with court, judge and courtroom; update every reminder when a date moves |
| Discovery | Police reports, body-camera video, lab results and statements arrive in batches | Log each production with the date received, store files by type and track what is still outstanding |
| Client contact | Jail calls and visits; meetings with family | Log each call and visit with date, length and attendees, and turn them into time entries |
| Motions and trial | Motions, plea negotiations and trial preparation | Track filing deadlines, tasks and witness lists against the court calendar |
| Sentencing and closing | Plea, verdict, sentencing or dismissal | Record the outcome, close the matter and keep the file for any appeal or post-conviction work |
Why are co-defendant conflict checks so important?
ABA Model Rule 1.7(a) says a concurrent conflict exists if “the representation of one client will be directly adverse to another client” or there is a significant risk the representation will be “materially limited” by responsibilities to another client. In criminal work the ABA’s comment on Rule 1.7 is blunt: “The potential for conflict of interest in representing multiple defendants in a criminal case is so grave that ordinarily a lawyer should decline to represent more than one codefendant.”
Co-defendants, cooperating witnesses and alleged victims may already be in your records as clients or callers. Conflict software should search all of them, including aliases, and record who reviewed the results and what was decided.
How should criminal defense software protect privileged material?
Model Rule 1.6(c) requires “reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or unauthorized access to, information relating to the representation of a client.” Defense files hold the client’s own account, investigator notes and strategy alongside discovery from the prosecution.
Look for per-matter permissions, a clear separation between discovery received and the firm’s own work product, an audit trail of who opened what, and a secure portal for sharing with the client or their family only what the client has agreed to share.
How should criminal defense software handle fees?
Contingent fees are off the table: Model Rule 1.5(d)(2) bars “a contingent fee for representing a defendant in a criminal case.” Most firms charge a flat fee, sometimes split by stage such as pre-trial and trial, or bill hourly. Rule 1.5(b) asks that the scope and the basis of the fee be communicated, “preferably in writing,” and a written agreement that says what happens if the case goes to trial avoids disputes later.
Fees paid in advance are covered by Model Rule 1.15(c), which says they go into a client trust account “to be withdrawn by the lawyer only as fees are earned or expenses incurred.” States differ on how this applies to flat fees, so set your software up to follow your state’s rule.
| Buyer checklist | Why it matters in criminal defense |
|---|---|
| Conflict search across co-defendants, witnesses, alleged victims and aliases | Rule 1.7 and the co-defendant comment |
| Court calendar that updates every reminder when a date is reset | Court dates move often and missing one has consequences for the client |
| Discovery log by production, with outstanding items tracked | Material arrives in batches over months |
| Separation of discovery from the firm’s work product, with per-matter permissions | Rule 1.6(c) and privilege |
| Flat-fee and stage-based billing; no contingency option on criminal matters | Rule 1.5(d)(2) bars contingent fees for criminal defendants |
| Advance-fee handling that follows your state’s trust rule | Rule 1.15(c) and state variations |
| Call and visit log that creates time entries | Client contact is frequent and should be recorded |
| Intake that captures the court, charge and next date on the first call | The first hearing can be days away |
For intake forms and conflict checks in more depth, read the legal intake software guide.
How does Perimattic Legal Practice Management work for criminal defense firms?
Perimattic Legal Practice Management is practice management for small and mid-size US law firms. What it does for criminal defense work:
- Client intake forms and a conflict-check workflow that searches every name collected, including co-defendants.
- Matter management with contacts, documents, tasks, deadlines and a calendar for court dates.
- Time tracking with timers and tenth-of-an-hour (6-minute) entries, plus expense tracking.
- Flat-fee and hourly billing, invoices and online payments.
- Trust (IOLTA) accounting with a separate trust ledger per client and three-way reconciliation reports.
- A client portal for secure messages and documents.
- Reporting on utilization, realization, collections and aged receivables.
A dedicated discovery-review tool and court e-filing are not included; discovery is stored and tracked as matter documents.
General information, not legal advice. ABA Model Rules and comments quoted as published on americanbar.org, checked October 22, 2026. Each state adopts its own version of the rules; follow your state bar’s rules and guidance.
More practice areas and guides
Criminal defense software, answered
Can a criminal defense lawyer charge a contingency fee?
No. ABA Model Rule 1.5(d)(2) says a lawyer shall not enter into an arrangement for, charge, or collect a contingent fee for representing a defendant in a criminal case. Criminal defense is usually billed as a flat fee, sometimes by stage, or hourly. Your software should not let a contingency billing type be set on a criminal matter.
Why do co-defendants matter for conflict checks?
Because representing more than one person charged in the same case is rarely possible. The ABA’s comment on Model Rule 1.7 says the potential for conflict in representing multiple criminal defendants is so grave that ordinarily a lawyer should decline to represent more than one codefendant. Software should search co-defendants, witnesses and alleged victims, not just the client.
Should a criminal defense firm log jail calls and visits?
Most firms do, for billing and for the file. A log of each call and visit, with the date, length and who attended, supports time entries and shows the client was kept informed. Treat jail calls as potentially recorded and keep privileged discussion for settings your jurisdiction protects; check local rules and facility policies.
Want court dates, flat fees and trust in one place?
Sign up and tell us how your firm runs matters and billing. Our team will get in touch to set you up.
Sign up